The Alternative Investment Management Association (AIMA) said in a release that it welcomed the US District Court for the Northern District of Texas’ decision to vacate the Securities and Exchange Commission’s (SEC) Dealer Rule on the grounds that it exceeds the regulator’s statutory authority and is, therefore, unauthorized. On this basis, the court has vacated the final rule in full.
AIMA, along with two other trade associations, challenged the Dealer Rule in March 2024, arguing that it should be vacated entirely because it exceeds the SEC’s statutory authority, is arbitrary and capricious and was adopted without adequate consideration of its impacts on efficiency, competition and capital formation.
AIMA CEO Jack Inglis said in a statement: “This outcome spares many hedge fund managers from facing the unenviable task of either attempting to comply with dealer registration in whatever form or curtailing their trading strategies that may have triggered one of the Dealer Rule’s arbitrary tests. Today’s ruling validates our decision to challenge the rule to protect the interests of our members and a wide variety of market participants from what would otherwise have been severe and adverse consequences. We also hope that today’s decision leads to the SEC rethinking its attempt to regulate by enforcement through individual cases it is pursuing that involve a literal reading of the dealer definition.”
The consortium of trade bodies argued that the rule should be vacated based on their arguments that, among other things:
- The SEC lacks the statutory authority to adopt the definition in the Dealer Rule because the rule captures firms that are not, and have never been considered, dealers and lacks any limiting principle.
- The SEC engaged in arbitrary and capricious decision-making, including by failing to adequately address the economic consequences of the Dealer Rule.
- The Dealer Rule is otherwise contrary to law because it imposes a burden on competition not necessary or appropriate in furtherance of the purposes of the Securities Exchange Act.